French Chicks Impacted Most: Activists Set Their Sights On Banning Tebuconazole

A French team conducted experiments using sparrow chicks and write in Environmental Research that their tests led to slower growth, with females impacted most. They targeted the common fungicide tebuconazole, popular on food crops because it can stop everything from necrotic ring spot to blights, mildews, and smuts. They compare it to the popular weedkiller glyphosate, which they claim has caused a decline in birds in Europe, despite scientists showing the top reason for bird population changes in various areas has been land use changes and not the use of pesticides lacking an Organic™ label.

A French team conducted experiments using sparrow chicks and write in Environmental Research that their tests led to slower growth, with females impacted most. 

They targeted the common fungicide tebuconazole, popular on food crops because it can stop everything from necrotic ring spot to blights, mildews, and smuts. They compare it to the popular weedkiller glyphosate, which they claim has caused a decline in birds in Europe, despite scientists showing the top reason for bird population changes in various areas has been land use changes and not the use of pesticides lacking an Organic™ label.

They bred domestics sparrows and exposed a control group to high concentrations of tebuconazole but data show no effect on the health, breeding period, number of eggs laid or hatching success of birds so they pivoted to being an observational study.

Using subjective criteria that places this in the EXPLORATORY pile rather than the science one, they declared chicks in the exposed group, and in particular females, showed reduced growth, they were 10% smaller, and a higher mortality rate after leaving the nest - 47% compared to 20% in the control group). It's not as unconvincing as fellow Europeans Gilles-Eric Seralini or Andrew Wakefield but it isn't compelling.

Regardless, they demand more funding to find new ways to declare the potentially harmful physiological effects of science, but the culture war really only shows why France is the most anti-science, even anti-vaccine, country in the world.

Categories

Hank Campbell

I founded Science 2.0® in 2006 and since then it has become the world's largest independent science communications site, with over 300,000,000 direct readers and reach approaching one billion. Revolutionizing the way scientists Communicate, Participate, Collaborate and Publish is the goal of Science 2.0 ® and it is a work in progress, so if you agree, sign up and help. I've also written for USA Today, Wall Street Journal, Wired, Investors Business Daily, Chicago Tribune, Detroit News, LA Times,The Hill, CNN, American Thinker, Federalist, San Diego Union-Tribune, New Scientist, Genetic… Read more